Guillermo
Staff
Say NO to putapathy
Posts: 117
|
Post by Guillermo on Sept 14, 2019 17:21:17 GMT 1
There is no such a “Suicidal Disposition” rubric in the TPB, Why?
Suicidal disposition, as well as many other mental symptoms, did NOT escape Hahnemann's acute observation and the association of fellow experimenters. We are fortunate to still keep that data.
However, many still wonder why Boenninghausen did not integrate a "suicide" rubric into the Therapeutic Pocket Book. The answer is simple.
|
|
|
Post by martinahumada on Oct 4, 2019 19:26:19 GMT 1
I think becouse it is included, for example, in the rubrics:
14 (sadness, mental depression),
11 (hopelessness, dispair),
2 (anxiety, fear)
Aurum
CD Introduction
Of melancholies, resembling that caused by gold, I have since cured quickly and permanently several persons who were seriously entertaining suicidal intentions, and, indeed, by small doses, which for the whole cure did not contain more than 3/100 or 9/100 of a grain of gold.
CD[5] Melancholy ; he imagines that he is not fitted for the world, he therefore longs for death, of which he thinks with the most intense delight. [Fz.].
CD [10] Great anguish, mounting even to suicide....
PMM Hah Introduction
Since then I have cured quickly and permanently of melancholia resembling that produced by gold many persons who had serious thoughts of commiting suicide, by small doses.
MMP 356: :Melancholy; he imagines he is unfitted for the world; he is filled with intense delight when he thinks of death, so that he longs to die. [Fz.
Nux v
MMP1236: Anxiety and anguish as if he had committed some crime.
1237:Great anxiety; he cannot rest in any place, and would rather die.
1238: After midnight very violent palpitation of the heart with extreme anxety, which urges him to commit suicide (aft. 5 h.).
1239: She deems the pain she suffers intolerable and will rather take her own life.
1240. Anxiety with impulse to commit suicide.
(Suicide; she throws herself from a height.)
Hep sulph
296 MMP: In the evening a frightful anxiety for two hours; he thought he must be ruined, and was sad to that degree that he could have killed himself.
|
|